Procedural difficulty for foreign law firms

The government has actually set the ball rolling to liberalize legal services, and allow entry of foreign law office in India. In a meeting chaired by secretary, ministry of law and justice, on Tuesday, there was in-principal arrangement amongst various stakeholders that consisted of representatives of The Bar Council of India, the legal fraternity, and the sector, on the relocation to open up legal services. However, there are distinctions amongst stakeholders on certain procedural problems to enable foreign law office to provide services in the country.


Last week, The Bar Council of India (the regulator of country’s legal services) flowed amongst its members the draft rules for foreign law firms and lawyers to practice in India even you can consult them for your fraud recovery . These included the terms for registration with The Bar Council that permits them to offer non-litigation legal opinion in non-Indian laws, in association with Indian law firms.

However, the draft guidelines drew in criticism from Society of Indian Law Firms (Silf) that has much big- and mid-sized law office as its members. The lobby group has actually been advocating a phased entry for foreign law firms and attorneys, spread over five to 7 years. “The draft guidelines do not show our position,” stated Lalit Bhasin, president, Silf.

An Indian law firm or lawyer is not allowed to publicize his or her services, but that is not the case with foreign companies, he stated. There are concerns around ownership structure of foreign law firms.

However, many foreign law practices are registered as business, or as Limited Liability Partnership (LLP’s). “The draft guidelines in their present type might encourage surrogate practice by foreign law practice in India,” said Bhasin.

30aNumerous in the legal fraternity feel that the federal government may have to amend the Advocates Act, 1961 that just allows an Indian citizen to practice law in the country.

A market representative, who attended the conference, invited the entry of foreign law firms to offer opinion on foreign law. The Ministry of Law & Justice has asked all the stakeholders to give a comprehensive discussion on their views in a meeting to be held first week of August.

Retired judge wants to resume law practice as financial requirement.

A Bar Council rule avoiding a retired High Court judge resuming practice as a lawyer is denying him of an essential right to work and make a livelihood, his lawyers have actually argued.

Barry White s wage and pension were significantly decreased following the economic crash and he previously informed the Bar Council he wishes to resume practice as a financial necessity.

Mr. Justice Max Barrett has started hearing the difficulty by Mr. White (71), who retired in 2014, to the Bar Council guideline avoiding retired judges resuming practice in a court equivalent to or lower than the one they commanded. In Mr. White s case, that means all courts listed below the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court.

30aThe guideline is based upon an 85-year-old case involving an application by a former judge of the Irish Appeal Court, James O Connor. Following the foundation of the Irish Free State, the court over which he presided was abolished and in 1929 he sought admission to practice as a solicitor.

Chief Justice Hugh Kennedy gave his application however held, as a basic guideline; it was contrary to public policy for a senior judge to return to legal practice. That judgment has been translated as avoiding retired judges resuming personal practice in a court equal to or less than the court which they were a judge.

Economic necessity

Following his retirement from the bench, Mr. White informed the Bar Council, the representative body of lawyers in Ireland, in a letter of his desire to resume practice as a lawyer due to financial necessity.

Throughout the nationwide emergency following the economic crash, Mr. White’s wage and pension were significantly minimized, it was specified.


He held discussions with the Bar Council and Minister for Justice on his application for a waiver of the Bar Council rule so he can resume practice but this was declined. He then started legal procedures.

Opening his case, John Rogers SC, with Cain Ferriter SC and Siobhan Phelan SC, for Mr. White, said the Bar Council choice breaches Mr. White’s human’s rights, including to work and make a source of income, something which is essential to him. Other premises of challenge consisted of arguments the guideline is anti-competitive and disproportionate.

The Bar Council has no jurisdiction to impose conditions on judges going back to practice and the Minister has no power to implement such limitations, it is also said.

Developing out of the Bar Council’s choice, the Minister for Justice has actually decided Mr. White, who had an extensive criminal Bar practice before being appointed a judge, was not regulated and chosen not to admit him to the criminal legal plan panel.

The Bar Council, represented by Michael Collins SC and Paul Sreenan SC, says Mr. White, when accepting the election to the bench in 2002, was aware of the disputed rule and its consequences.

30aIt is said the rule, contained in the Bar Council s Code of Conduct, has genuine and affordable objectives created to safeguard the integrity and self-reliance of the administration of justice. It is likewise denied the guideline disproportionately disrupts Mr. White’s rights, consisting of to earn an income.

The court heard Mr. White has actually provided a variety of tasks to resolve specific concerns of the Bar Council, consisting of not to act in cases which he had commanded or including obstacles to his own judgments and not to use any secret information gotten as a judge.

He rejects any idea judges would favor him or his clients just because he had been a judge himself.

As a judge, Mr. White commanded lots of high profile criminal trials, including of Eamon Lillis, founded guilty of the murder of his better half Celine, and Joe O Reilly, serving a life sentence for the murder of his other half Rachel.

The case is anticipated to last a number of days.

Temple’s law dean promoted to provost

Temple University early Tuesday early morning raised law school dean JoAnne A. Epps to provost, its number-two position, replacing Hai-Lung Dai, who was eliminated from the post recently.

The visit, subject to approval by the board of trustees, would be permanent – not interim, as universities often do so they can introduce a nationwide search.


Epps, 65, who has invested 31 years at the law school, the last eight as its dean, was appointed by President Neil D. Theobald. Her title will consist of senior vice president and chief academic policeman also, and she will manage academics across the university’s 17 schools and colleges and 12 administrative offices.

“JoAnne’s impressive record in teaching, student success, variety, and social justice, combined with her long-standing dedication to Temple and the city of Philadelphia, makes her ideally suited for this important leadership function,” Theobald stated in a statement.

Gregory N. Mandel, a law professor and associate dean of research, will step in as interim law school dean, Theobald stated.

Epps stated she had not sought the post and only recently discovered that Theobald wanted her to take it.

“I believe the university remains in a terrific location, and if I can assist contribute to its research study and academic and teaching excellence, I’m happy to provide my efforts,” said Epps, a Yale Law School grad who spent nine years as a trial lawyer before joining Temple.

30aShe acknowledged that she was walking into a questionable circumstance. Dai, a chemist who continues to be a tenured faculty member has actually employed a lawyer, and some professors have actually decried his ouster, launching a petition to urge the board to scrutinize Theobald’s decision.

The university released a brief statement recently saying Dai was being launched of his management duties, but offered no reason. The same day of the statement the university acknowledged it had a $22 million space in its financial-aid budget plan for benefit scholarships and had taken actions to stabilize the spending plan. Theobald was not pleased with the over expenditure, while Dai protected it, sources said, and the concern caused a rift between Theobald and his second-in-command.

Epps stated she comprehends the faculty have concerns however said workers problems are personal.

“What I truly hope is that I will have the ability to ensure the professors and students and other members of the community that the things about Temple’s momentum that we’re all so excited about, I will lend every fiber of my being to continue,” she stated.

Because the decision was so unexpected, she said she had made no plans yet for changes in the office, nor has Theobald offered her a program.

30a“I’m wishing to continue to build on Temple’s strong research commitment and continue to attract world-class professors,” she stated.

Patrick O’Connor, chair of the board of trustees as well as a lawyer, called Epps “a design jurist.”

“She is a thoughtful listener, strong leader, and a knowledgeable consensus builder – all necessary qualities for the position of provost,” he stated in a statement.

Epps, a local of Cheltenham Township, got her bachelor’s degree from Trinity College in Hartford, Conn., in 1973. She was introduced to the school by a young Trinity College student who had actually checked out Cheltenham High School when she was a senior to recruit young minority students. He drove her to Trinity for a go to with the dean of admissions, and quickly she had an offer of tuition help.

Her daddy was a machinist and later an installment-loan collector, and her mom a secretary at Temple, who retired in the 1980’s. Epps worked as a cashier in the Temple bookstore when she was 16 but didn’t imagine becoming an Owl – she didn’t wish to go to school where her mother worked.

“But that summer gave me a feeling of belonging to the city that I had not had,” said Epps, who kept in mind that she had actually mostly grown up in a white neighborhood.

After Yale, she became deputy city attorney in Los Angeles in 1976 and in 1980 returned to Philadelphia to sign up with the United States Attorney’s Office. She started at Temple law in 1985 and was called dean in 2008.

In 2014, she was appointed by Mayor Michael Nutter to chair a Police Oversight Board accountable for ensuring Philadelphia carries out suggestions of a Justice Department report crucial of policeman’s use of lethal force. She’s also on the city ethics commission and continues to act as a court-appointed monitor of city efforts to revamp stop-and-frisk strategies by police.

She presided over the law school at a difficult time when registrations nationally have declined. Throughout her leadership, the school moved into the leading 50 in U.S. News & World Report rankings, began a center for compliance and ethics, and created the Stephen and Sandra Sheller Center for Social Justice, which has taken on the issue of language access in the courts for non-English speakers.

“I like what it represents,” she stated of the Sheller. “Our students are learning how they can be helpful.”

Growing up in the 1960’s, Epps never envisioned how her life would unfold.

Her profession aspirations were set: She said she wished to end up being a legal secretary, like the fictional character Della Street on her preferred show, Perry Mason.

She nearly left Trinity after her sophomore year, she stated, because she wasn’t getting the typing and shorthand abilities she needed to land that job.

30aThen a Trinity dean suggested she end up being a lawyer, something she had actually never ever considered.

“I had actually never ever met a lawyer, a male or a woman, white or black,” she said. “I reversed course. I said that’s not a bad concept.”

While she loved the nurturing environment of Trinity, she stated she discovered it hard to fit in at Yale, where she said the majority of the rest of her class were white students from privileged households.

“Very couple of were first-generation college or law school,” she stated. “Many were children or grandchildren of attorneys and judges. They showed up with an understanding of the setting.”

There was no effort to truly help her or the few others like her discover how to cope, she said.

Pin It on Pinterest